• Missed my book tour? See me on C-SPAN3 TV! Details Here

Who Killed Dr. Joseph Warren? The Forensic Analysis (Part 3 of 4)

This post is part 3 (read part 2) of a 4-part series delving into the particulars of the death of Dr. Joseph Warren, which includes posts by guest contributor Dr. Sam Forman, author of the forthcoming biography Dr. Joseph Warren: The Boston Tea Party, Bunker Hill, and the Birth of American Liberty (pictured to the right), due out December 1. --Derek

I am happy to be continue as a guest blogger, addressing the facts and legends of Joseph Warren's heroics at the Battle of Bunker Hill. In the course of writing the upcoming definitive biography Dr. Joseph Warren: The Boston Tea Party, Bunker Hill, and the Birth of American Liberty, I based my brief account of Warren's battlefield demise in part on an extensive forensic analysis of the old pictures of Joseph Warren’s skull. These are some of the oldest known medical or anatomic photographs, so employing them in all-new forensics constitutes an unusual application of forensics.

1856 Photos of Dr. Joseph Warren's Skull from Three Directions

1856 Photos of Dr. Joseph Warren's Skull (revealing a shot entered from front and exited the back of skull). These copies courtesy of the family of Lester L. Luntz, D.D.S., refined by the author.1 Re-use of these images require permission!

Derek Beck remarked that Joseph Warren’s fatal entry wound, above the left upper false teeth in the maxillary bone of the skull, seemed smaller than one might expect of a British infantry musket ball. Those balls were cast of lead, about ¾ of an inch in diameter, or 0.75 caliber. "Caliber" is firearms-speak for the diameter of gun barrels and their projectiles, expressed in hundredths of an inch. By comparison, a fearsome modern gun considered to be a large caliber is a 0.44 caliber magnum revolver (often the decimal is dropped when spoken, thus a "44 magnum"). The old British infantry muskets fired a much larger projectile.

But we have a big problem. How could one say for certain what the size of the entry wound was, or anything in the old picture for that matter, without knowing the scale of the picture? The photographer did not put a ruler into the frame, a circumstance leaving us without reliable numbers for the sizing of anything.

Or does it? What if we could obtain average measures of a large number of similar Caucasian, adult male skulls of Northern European origin, and approximate a scale for the old picture and Warren's skull? If we could do this, our estimated scale would be data-based. We could have some confidence in the sizes of things, and any inferences we might draw from them that may be of importance to Joseph Warren's story. Does anyone have a few dozen white male heads lying around?

Indeed, someone has. Several decades ago a Harvard anthropology professor - the late W. W. Howells - took hundreds of thousands of measures of statistically large numbers of skulls of men and women of various races and ethnicities, to the delight of physical anthologists, forensic pathologists, plastic surgeons, and others interested in the fine points of skulls.2

A standard musketball of the colonial era, 0.75 caliber, like those bullets fired by the Brown Bess as carried by the common British soldier.

A standard musketball of the colonial era, 0.75 caliber, like those bullets fired by the Brown Bess as carried by the common British soldier. The flat spot on the ball is likely where the ball’s sprue was cut off after casting, rather than indicative of, say, an impact into a skull.

Professor Howells noted that adult skull sizes are much less likely to be impacted by nutrition and other environmental factors in the way long bones are. Heredity rules relative to the size of your head.

Digging deeply into Professor Howell’s tabulations, I found detailed data on over 150 Northern European skulls of  white men who died in recent centuries. Included were 55 Norwegian skulls from the Anatomical Institute of the University of Oslo, 54 Hungarian skulls from the Natural History Museum of Budapest, and 56 Austrian skulls from Carinthia. Of Howell’s various measurements, Orbital Breadth (OBB) varied the least among these three Caucasian groups. What variation there was among the skulls was quantified statistically with standard deviations. OBB was 40.4 millimeters (range 38.95-43.24, +/- 2 standard deviations) for the middling population, the Norwegians.

Returning to Warren’s skull photos, I concentrated on the 7/8ths frontal view, having it manipulated digitally to a full frontal view. This eliminated the distortion intoducerd by the rotated angle. Putting calipers to the picture, I measured the relative size of Joseph Warren’s OBB at 139 pixels; and the fatal entry wound at 47 pixels.

Using Howell’s actually-measured average OBB, I could set up a ratio calculating the size of the entry wound. Recalling for some of us 6th grade arithmetic:

Dr. Warren’s OBB in pixels is to the entry wound in pixels, as average OBB in millimeters is to X in millimeters, where X is the diameter of the entry wound.

Cranking the numbers and applying the confidence interval, the entry wound was 1.37 centimeters or 0.54 caliber (range 0.50-0.58 caliber, +/- 2 SDs). 0.54 caliber is considerably smaller than the 0.75 caliber Brown Bess standard infantry musket. Even allowing for some noise in the methodology, 0.54 caliber is much smaller than 0.75. A penetrating entry bullet wound through bone could not possibly be smaller than the projectile that made it.

I want to assure the reader that this "Crime Scene Investigation" approach was deep background to my definitive new biography of Joseph Warren. I did it to rest the account of Dr. Warren's heroic demise on a rock-solid foundation. It was all the more important because what really happened was very unlike most eyewitness accounts, contemporary beliefs, legends, and standard history books.

The Conclusion Next Monday: So just who killed Dr. Joseph Warren?

  1. Third generation skull photos taken of the lost originals by Dr. Luntz for his 1973 Handbook for Dental Identification, published by J. B. Lippincott Co, Philadelphia. The Luntz copies are now in Harvard's Countway Library of Medicine, Boston. Original daguerreotypes probably taken on May 6, 1856.
  2. Howells, W.W. Cranial Variation in Man - a Study by Multivariate Analysis of Patterns of Difference among Recent Human Populations. Vol. 67, Appendix C. Papers of the Peabody Museum of Archeology and Ethnology. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University, 1973.
 Derek's Book

About Sam Forman

Dr. Sam Forman is a fellow historian that is especially interested in Dr. Joseph Warren.
Tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Who Killed Dr. Joseph Warren? The Forensic Analysis (Part 3 of 4)

  1. Pingback: Who Killed Dr. Joseph Warren? (Part 4 of 4) « "1775" – a forthcoming history book by Derek W. Beck

  2. Derek Beck says:

    Thank you to Mr. Keith Francik for the educational email, where he informed me that the flat spot was due to the sprue being cut off. My original theory was that the mold was not completely filled with lead when it was cast. Keith’s explanation is much more likely the case, and I thank him for it. I have updated the above caption accordingly.

  3. Pingback: Who Killed Dr. Joseph Warren? (Part 4 of 4) - Derek W. Beck

Leave a Reply